or “Common Lisp is not very functional-programming oriented”. What are the options ?
map is uncommon and there is no short words like
for functional composition. Right ?
edit see those snippets.
Map and filter
Indeed, there are 8 or so
map functions. The one we’re used to is
mapcar. The simple
map needs a second argument to specify its return
(map 'list (lambda…. “filter” is named
mapcan can also be useful. It concatenates the items into one
list. So with
mapcar we get a list of lists with our items, with
mapcan simply a list of our items.
=> improved in cl21. It defines the usual
keep-if and more functional verbs:
sum,… in addition to
Note: remember that we still have access to
cl symbols in CL21.
Lack of functional composition ? There is the Series library since 1989 that seems great, it lets us “write our program in a functional style without any runtime penalty at all !” [malisper on his blog post]
But yes again, it has not the modern vocabulary we expect and it seems abandonware (and its documentation is an old pdf paper but now hopefully this wiki is better).
CL21 has an operator to compose functions: https://github.com/cl21/cl21/wiki/Language-Difference-between-CL21-and-Common-Lisp#function
Threading macros (pipes)
We have two packages in Quicklisp:
- cl-arrows defines
->>and the generalized ones
-<>>. At the time of writing it has two unanswered PRs to add more, like the “when-guarded”-“nil shortcuting diamond wand”
- arrow-macros is a bit more
complete but has more dependencies (it needs a code walker) which
are not portable (failed on ECL, Allegro, ABCL, Clisp). It has the
We have the nice FSet, the functional collection for Common Lisp.
Anaphoric macros (for shorter lambdas)
I like anaphoric macros but I didn’t find one ready to use in a library to write shorter lambdas. The first macro I wrote was directly to mimick elisp’s
dash.el excellent library:
(defmacro --map (form list) `(mapcar (lambda (it) ,form) ,list))
so than we can write
(mapcar (* it 2) '(2 3))
(mapcar (lambda (it) (* it 2) '(2 3))).
This macro is very simple. It should be in a library, I don’t want to copy-paste it in every project of mine. => in CL21 ? In Anaphora ?
=> Personnally I’m very happy with cl21’s short lambdas (that were not documented…):
(map ^(foo-bar %) items)
(lm (x)…. Unused arguments will be ignored automatically.
I also quite like the Arc way of doing, that I found in the Clamp project. Arc is another language and Clamp is more of a POC I guess.
For shorter lambdas we also have f-underscore, that I see used in the wild. It defines some macros to write shorter lambdas:
fis a synonym for lambda
f0is a lambda that takes 0 arguments
f_takes one, accessible in
f_%ignores its rest argument
mis a lambda “that has a macro-lambda-list instead of an ordinary lambda-list”.
You might like Trivia for pattern matching too.
Hope this helps !